I took the cookies and numbered them one through three. The Common Bond one was incredibly easy to tell apart since we've had it so often. One was from Michael's Cookie Jar, which we've had a few times before, and the other was from Porch Swing Desserts, whose cookies we had never tried.
I made ballots. If we had a working printer, I would have done that, but use what you've got, right? Each cookie was rated on a scale of 1-5 on its chocolateyness, texture, and overall deliciousness.
His and Hers Ballots
Cookie #3 was awful. Cookie #1 was fine, but Andrew didn't love it. Chocolate chip cookies are his favorite thing, though. so he's pretty picky. Cookie #2 was nearly perfect and was the resounding winner.
My only complaint, if you can call it one, is it's so soft it's almost cakey. The chocolate is the best, though.
Sorry, Michael's Cookie Jar (#1) and Porch Swing Desserts (#3), but Cookie #2 was just too great.
Please tell me you've done something equally ridiculous in the name of having a reason to break out the camera or make a blog post from nothing...